Master of science-level of the Bologna process in Ingegneria Gestionale - Torino Master of science-level of the Bologna process in Ingegneria Gestionale (Engineering And Management) - Torino Master of science-level of the Bologna process in Ingegneria Gestionale (Engineering And Management) - Torino
Strategic Management and Organization Design are deeply intertwined disciplinary areas in management. In this course their perspectives are integrated in order to show how firms are able to create superior economic value through appropriate strategic decisions related to market positioning, investments in technology resources and organization design.
In so doing, the course aims at equipping students in management with the fundamentals of strategic thinking that is needed to firms to undertake appropriate competitive actions. The foundations of strategic thinking lie in an array of concepts, frameworks and techniques that is needed by managers and business analysts to conduct strategic analysis and to take appropriate decisions accordingly. As such, the course illustrates the fundamentals of strategic analyses, giving a high emphasis on the role that technological change have in shaping competitive dynamics and in offering new ways to develop valuable products for customers. In so doing, the course explores the interdependencies that strategic management has with the main issues that managers have to deal with when they design the firm’s organizational structure and business processes. In this regard, the course discusses the fit between the firm’s strategy, its organization structure and its competitive environment that is at the origin of a firm’s high competitiveness.
At the accomplishment of the course, students should be able to think according to a strategic perspective in dealing with the traditional tools of strategic analysis in order to assess how in a given industry firms should take decisions by considering the threats and opportunities related to global competition and demand, technological change, and other competitive forces existing in their relevant market.
In the curriculum of a student in Management and Engineering, Strategic management and Organization design have a central importance irrespective of the choices and the chances that students will have in the job market. For example, a graduate in Engineering and Management may work as a strategic analyst in the Strategic Planning department or a in a consulting company and can be thus involved in making analysis whose outcomes are inputs to the strategic actions/decisions made by the top management team. For graduates working in other functional departments (e.g. Manufacturing, Logistics , Sales, Management of Information Systems) studying Strategic management will be important to understand how the firm’s business strategy and the trends in its competitive environment (technology evolution, global competition and demand, etc.) influence strategy and operations within each function and require an alignment between the business strategy and functional strategies/operations. In all cases, progress in career always means being required more managerial skills and not only competencies that are specific of the task and the functional department (a «T-shaped» competence profile).
Strategy and organization are closely interconnected areas of management and constitute a fundamental component of graduate education in Management Engineering. This course integrates the two perspectives to examine how firms create and sustain superior economic value through strategic choices and organizational design.
The course develops the foundations of strategic thinking: the ability to identify the relevant features of a competitive situation, distinguish between alternative explanations, evaluate strategic options, and formulate decisions that are coherent with both the external environment and the firm's internal resources and capabilities.
Students are introduced to the main concepts, frameworks, and analytical tools used in strategic management to assess industries, firms, competitive advantage, corporate boundaries, innovation, internationalization, and organizational design. Particular attention is devoted to the role of technological change in reshaping competitive dynamics, industry structures, organizational arrangements, and opportunities for value creation and value capture. A central premise of the course is that strategy cannot be reduced to the mechanical application of analytical frameworks. Strategic decisions are typically made under conditions of incomplete information, ambiguity, uncertainty, and competing objectives. Accordingly, the course combines conceptual knowledge with the development of contextual judgment: the ability to determine what can legitimately be inferred from the available evidence, make assumptions explicit, recognize relevant trade-offs, and formulate defensible recommendations.
The course also examines the interdependence between strategy and organization. It analyzes how the effectiveness of a strategic choice depends on the organizational structures, coordination mechanisms, and capabilities through which that strategy is implemented.
The course aims at equipping students with the concepts, frameworks and techniques needed by managers to conduct analysis and to take appropriate decisions accordingly. As such, the course illustrates the fundamentals of strategy and organization, putting emphasis on the role that technological change and innovation have in shaping competitive dynamics and in offering new ways to develop valuable products for customers.
At the accomplishment of the course, students should be able to apply the traditional tools of strategic, organizational and marketing analysis in order to assess how in a given industry firms should take strategic decisions taking into account the threats and opportunities related to global competition and demand, technological change, and other competitive forces existing in their relevant market.
2.1 Knowledge and Understanding
Students will be able to:
• understand the fundamental concepts and theoretical perspectives of strategic management and organizational design;
• explain the determinants of industry attractiveness and competitive advantage;
• distinguish among alternative sources of cost advantage, differentiation, and value creation;
• understand how resources and capabilities contribute to the creation and sustainability of competitive advantage;
• understand the economic rationale underlying firm boundaries, make-or-buy decisions, outsourcing, partnerships, and vertical integration;
• understand the main organizational structures and coordination mechanisms and the conditions under which they are appropriate;
• understand how technological change, innovation, industry evolution, and internationalization affect firms' strategic and organizational choices.
2.2 Applying Knowledge and Understanding
Students will be able to:
• apply strategic frameworks to the analysis of real firms, industries, and competitive situations;
• identify which analytical framework is appropriate to a given problem and recognize the limits of its applicability;
• distinguish between conclusions that are supported by case evidence and conclusions that would require additional information;
• evaluate alternative strategic actions using both qualitative and quantitative evidence;
• assess the consistency among a firm's competitive environment, strategy, resources and capabilities, organizational structure, and corporate boundaries.
2.3 Making Judgements
Students will be able to:
• formulate strategic judgments under conditions of incomplete and ambiguous information;
• identify the assumptions underlying an analysis and assess their implications;
• distinguish evidence-based reasoning from unsupported pattern recognition or mechanical framework application;
• identify and evaluate strategic trade-offs;
• develop context-specific recommendations rather than generic prescriptions;
• recognize the limitations and uncertainty associated with strategic decisions.
2.4 Communication Skills
Students will be able to:
• communicate strategic analyses and recommendations clearly, concisely, and logically;
• support claims with relevant evidence;
• articulate and defend a position while engaging constructively with alternative interpretations;
• contribute effectively to collective decision-making processes.
2.5 Learning and Teamwork Skills
Students will be able to:
• independently analyze new strategic problems using the concepts developed during the course;
• integrate information originating from multiple sources;
• revise an initial interpretation when new evidence becomes available;
• making decisions in teams under conditions of uncertainty, information overload, and time pressure.
To take part to the course students must have attended courses in the following disciplines: Financial and Managerial Accounting, Economics, Operations Management and Applied Statistics.
To take part to the course students must have attended courses in the following disciplines: Financial and Managerial Accounting, Economics, Operations Management and Applied Statistics.
Part I – The tools of Strategy Analysis
• Strategy and the Strategic Management Process
• The external environment and Industry analysis: the fundamentals
• The Analysis of the Firm: Evaluating the Firm’s Resources and Capabilities
Part II. The organization of the firm
• The Vertical Integration of the Firm
• Fundamentals of Organization Design
Part III. The strategy in the firm’s context
• Business Strategies: Cost Leadership and Product Differentiation
• Strategies in technology-based industries and the management of innovation
Part I – The tools of Strategy Analysis
• Strategy and the Strategic Management Process
• The external environment and Industry analysis: the fundamentals
• The Analysis of the Firm: Evaluating the Firm’s Resources and Capabilities
Part II. The organization of the firm
• The Vertical Integration of the Firm
• Fundamentals of Organization Design
Part III. The strategy in the firm’s context
• Business Strategies: Cost Leadership and Product Differentiation
• Strategies in technology-based industries and the management of innovation
Organizzazione dell'insegnamento
The learning method will be based on combining two types of lectures centred on two different and complementary approaches. Traditional frontal lectures will illustrate relevant theories and concepts from prominent scholars in strategic management and their application in tools for strategic analysis.
Laboratories will be based on a collective case study discussion in which students will be required to apply the tools and the concepts learned during the lectures on theory. Case study discussion will require that students will read material that will be provided by the instructors in advance. Finally, the talks of some invited speakers from business community (e.g. managers with an international experience) will provide an important complement to frontal lectures and laboratories. These talks will take place outside the normal course schedule.
When students are presented with a case, they place themselves in the role of the decision maker: read through the situation and identify the problem they are faced with.
To get the most out of cases, students read and reflect on the case individually, and then meet in learning teams before class to "warm up" and discuss their findings with other classmates. In class—under the questioning and guidance of the professor—students probe underlying issues, compare different alternatives, and suggest courses of action in light of the organization's objectives.
Learning Method
The course combines complementary learning methods designed to develop both conceptual knowledge and strategic judgment.
Lectures
Lectures introduce the theoretical foundations of strategic management and organizational design and explain the concepts, models, and analytical frameworks used throughout the course.
The objective is not only to understand individual frameworks, but also to recognize:
• the assumptions on which they are based;
• the questions they are designed to address;
• the relationships among different frameworks;
• the conditions under which a framework can or cannot be appropriately applied.
Case-Based Learning
A substantial part of the course uses the case method. Students analyze real or realistic business situations and assume the role of decision-makers confronted with strategic problems. Case analysis requires students to identify the relevant problem, select and interpret the available evidence, evaluate alternative courses of action, and formulate a defensible recommendation.
Effective case learning requires:
1. individual preparation before class;
2. discussion and comparison of interpretations with other students;
3. active participation in classroom discussion.
Case discussions are deliberately centered on situations for which there is not necessarily a single objectively correct decision and in which strategic analysis is needed to identify relevant variables and frameworks to understand the competitive context in which a firm is situated. Their purpose is therefore not to identify a predetermined answer, but to develop the ability to construct a rigorous argument from incomplete evidence, recognize uncertainty, and evaluate competing strategic alternatives.
Business Simulation
Students will also participate in a team-based business simulation designed to reproduce a dynamic managerial decision-making environment.
Unlike a written case, in which the available information is fixed, the simulation requires teams to interpret evolving information, make sequential decisions, assess their consequences, and adapt their strategy over time.
Course Language and Attendance
The language of the course is English.
Lectures, teaching materials, slides, case discussions, the Business Game, the written examination, interaction with instructors, and any oral examination are conducted in English. Attendance is strongly recommended but not mandatory.
Regular attendance is particularly important for case discussions, where learning depends on interaction among participants, and for the Business Game.
Students remain responsible for the complete course content and assigned teaching materials irrespective of attendance.
A. Custom Book, that combines chapters from :
a. Grant, R. Contemporary Strategic analysis: Text and Cases, John Wiley, 8th edition (or the Text version without cases, but students are required to prepare some case studies from this book)
b. Besanko, Dranove, Economics of Strategy, John Wiley
The book is available on the campus’s CELID bookstore.
B. Excerpt of H. Mintzberg's book, The structuring of the organization. (delivered by the instructors)
C. Collection of articles provided by the instructors and made available on the course’s web platform
D. Case study package, available on Harvard Business Publishing
E. Slides, made available on the course’s web platform
The course uses the following materials:
1. Grant, R. M., Contemporary Strategy Analysis: Text and Cases, John Wiley, or the corresponding text-only edition. Earlier editions may also be used, as the core conceptual structure remains substantially consistent, although examples and cases may differ.
2. Selected excerpts from Besanko et al., Economics of Strategy, made available by the instructors where applicable.
3. Selected academic articles and articles from the international business and financial press, made available through the course platform.
4. A collection of case studies distributed through Harvard Business Publishing, which students may be required to purchase.
5. Lecture slides and additional materials made available through the Portale della Didattica.
Slides; Libro di testo; Esercizi; Esercizi risolti; Strumenti di simulazione;
Lecture slides; Text book; Exercises; Exercise with solutions ; Simulation tools;
Modalita di esame: Prova orale obbligatoria; Elaborato progettuale in gruppo; Prova scritta in aula tramite PC con l'utilizzo della piattaforma di ateneo;
Exam: Compulsory oral exam; Group project; Computer-based written test in class using POLITO platform;
...
The written exam is a closed book assessment. The main goal of the exam is to assess the student's capability of applying the tools of strategic analysis effectively and of applying logical induction to link an assigned case study with the body of theories discussed during the course.
The final grade is the sum of three components.
a. A written Exam, whose maximum grade is 26. The grading breakdown is as follows: i) a question of 14 points, based on the interpretation and analysis of a case study; ii) a question of 4-5 points on case studies discussed in the lectures; iii) a question of 4 points where students are required to recall the main tenets of a theory discussed during lectures, iv) a true-and-false series of questions (six), whose maximum score is 3 points
b. An Optional Oral Exam.
c. A mandatory team work regarding the strategic analysis of an industry and the definition of strategic recommendations for successfully competing within the industry (maximum grade: 6 points)
To pass the exam the total grade must be equal or higher than 18 on a 0-30 scale.
Sample copy of written exams proposed in the last academic years will be made available to students during the semester
Gli studenti e le studentesse con disabilita o con Disturbi Specifici di Apprendimento (DSA), oltre alla segnalazione tramite procedura informatizzata, sono invitati a comunicare anche direttamente al/la docente titolare dell'insegnamento, con un preavviso non inferiore ad una settimana dall'avvio della sessione d'esame, gli strumenti compensativi concordati con l'Unita Special Needs, al fine di permettere al/la docente la declinazione piu idonea in riferimento alla specifica tipologia di esame.
Exam: Compulsory oral exam; Group project; Computer-based written test in class using POLITO platform;
Assessment and Grading Policy
Student performance is assessed through two components:
1. an individual written examination, worth a maximum of 23 points; an oral examination may follow (more information are presented below) to validate and integrate the evaluation obtained in the written examination.
2. a mandatory team-based Business Game, worth a maximum of 10 points.
The two scores are added directly. The resulting score constitutes the student's provisional final grade, subject to any oral examination where applicable.
To pass the course, both of the following requirements must be satisfied:
• the student must obtain at least 14/23 in the written examination;
• the resulting final grade must be at least 18/30.
The Business Game cannot therefore compensate for a written examination score below 14/23.
Because the written examination and Business Game together provide a maximum of 33 points, scores above 30 are recorded as 30/30 or 30/30 cum laude. The award of cum laude is at the instructors' discretion and reflects an overall judgment of outstanding performance. In addition to the assessment scores, this judgment may take into account the quality and consistency of the student's interaction and participation in class throughout the course.
Written Examination
Format
The written examination is an individual, closed-book, in-person examination.
Maximum score: 23/23; Minimum written-exam threshold: 14/23; Duration: 100 minutes
There is no remote or online examination option.
During the examination, students may not use:
• textbooks;
• lecture notes or personal notes;
• computers or tablets;
• smartphones;
• smartwatches;
• smartglasses;
• electronic communication devices;
• generative AI systems or any other AI-based tool;
• any other unauthorized material or device.
Sample questions and examples of the examination format will be discussed or provided during the course.
Structure of the Written Examination
Section Format Questions Points
A. Conceptual Knowledge and Theoretical Reasoning Multiple choice 10 10
B. Case-Based Application Multiple choice 3 3
C. Contextual Strategic Judgement Open-ended 2-3 10
Total 15-16 23
The examination deliberately combines different forms of assessment because knowledge of strategic concepts, the ability to apply them correctly, and the ability to formulate an independent strategic judgment represent distinct learning outcomes.
Because Sections A and B together account for a maximum of 13 points, students cannot reach the minimum written-exam threshold of 14/23 solely through the multiple-choice sections. Passing the written examination therefore requires demonstrating at least some ability to independently formulate a contextual strategic analysis in Section C.
Assessment Logic of the Written Examination
Section A — Conceptual Knowledge and Theoretical Reasoning: 10 points
This section assesses whether students understand the fundamental concepts, theories, and analytical frameworks covered in the course.
Questions may assess:
• correct definitions;
• distinctions between conceptually related ideas;
• relationships among different theories and frameworks;
• the assumptions underlying a model;
• the contexts in which a framework is appropriate;
• the limitations of a framework.
Conceptual knowledge is a necessary foundation for strategic analysis. However, knowing a framework is not equivalent to being able to use it appropriately. The subsequent sections therefore assess whether students can transfer conceptual knowledge to specific decision contexts.
Section B — Case-Based Application (3 points)
This section assesses students' ability to reason from the specific evidence provided in a case.
Its central purpose is to determine whether students can distinguish between:
• conclusions that are legitimately supported by the available evidence; and
• conclusions that may be theoretically plausible but would require information that the case does not provide.
This distinction is fundamental to rigorous strategic analysis.
A common analytical error is to recognize a familiar theoretical pattern and assume that all its implications apply to the case. Section B assesses whether students can distinguish conclusions supported by the available evidence from those that remain hypotheses.
8.3 Section C — Contextual Strategic Judgement (10 points)
Section C provides the primary assessment of students' ability to independently produce a strategic analysis.
Students are presented with case situations characterized by some combination of:
• incomplete information;
• ambiguity;
• competing objectives;
• strategic uncertainty;
• multiple defensible courses of action.
These questions may refer to cases discussed during the course or to new situations developed by the instructors using material drawn from business and financial sources such as The Financial Times, The Economist, and The Wall Street Journal.
There is not necessarily a single predetermined solution.
Students are assessed on the quality of the reasoning used to reach and defend their conclusions.
1. Use of case-specific evidence
Arguments must be anchored in concrete facts and information contained in the case. Generic statements that could apply equally well to almost any company or industry do not demonstrate adequate case analysis and will therefore receive limited credit, even when conceptually correct.
2. Quality of reasoning and awareness of trade-offs
Students must demonstrate that they understand the implications and limitations of their analysis. High-quality responses make assumptions explicit, identify relevant uncertainties, consider plausible alternatives, and recognize the trade-offs associated with different strategic choices. Frameworks should support the reasoning rather than substitute for it.
3. Operational relevance
Recommendations must be sufficiently specific to indicate what the firm should actually do. An abstract statement such as “the firm should differentiate” or “the company should build dynamic capabilities” is not, by itself, an actionable strategic recommendation. Students must explain what the proposed course of action means in the context of the specific firm and situation.
Section C therefore assesses the course's central individual learning objective: the ability to formulate a rigorous and context-sensitive strategic judgment rather than mechanically reproduce a previously learned analytical template.
Oral Examination
An oral examination may take place under two distinct circumstances.
1 Oral Examination Requested by the Student
Students who obtain a provisional final grade above 24/30 may request an additional oral examination. The purpose of this optional oral examination is to allow students to further demonstrate the depth, robustness, and transferability of their understanding of the course content.
The oral examination is not automatically grade-improving. Based on the quality of the student's performance, it may result in either an increase or a decrease of the provisional final grade, normally within an interval of approximately ±3 points.
By requesting the oral examination, the student therefore accepts both possible outcomes.
2 Oral Verification Required by the Instructors
The instructors reserve the right to require a mandatory oral verification when the written examination warrants additional evidence regarding the validity, consistency, or depth of the preparation demonstrated by the student.
The purpose of this oral verification is not to provide a second opportunity to pass the examination or to compensate automatically for weaknesses in the written examination. Rather, it is an integral part of the assessment process aimed at determining whether the performance observed in the written examination accurately reflects the student's individual understanding and ability to reason about strategic problems.
The oral verification follows a rule-based logic. Students are not selected randomly or solely on the basis of ad hoc discretionary judgment. With at least a three-day notice, an oral verification may be required for students falling into one of the following categories:
• Written-exam scores in an intermediate range close to the minimum passing threshold of 14/23. This category does not include clearly insufficient written examinations, for which the result is already conclusive. The purpose of the oral verification is to determine whether a borderline written performance provides sufficient evidence that the minimum learning outcomes have been achieved.
• Particularly high written-exam scores (higher or equal than 20 in the written examination). In these cases, the purpose is to verify that an exceptionally strong or fluent written performance reflects genuine and transferable understanding of the course concepts and an ability to reason independently, rather than merely the effective reproduction of learned material.
• A particularly weak performance in Section C — Contextual Strategic Judgement, even when the overall written-exam score is at or above the minimum passing threshold. Because Section C assesses one of the core learning outcomes of the course, a markedly weak performance in this section warrants additional verification of the student's ability to formulate a rigorous, evidence-based, and context-sensitive strategic judgment.
The oral verification will normally start from an argument, conclusion, or analytical choice contained in the student's written examination. The student may be asked to explain the reasoning underlying a specific answer, defend it against alternative interpretations, and apply the same concepts to a brief new situation.
The oral verification is brief and normally lasts approximately 5–7 minutes. It concerns the individual learning outcomes assessed through the examination. Performance in the Business Game is not assessed as part of the oral verification. As a general rule, the oral verification may result in the confirmation, an increase, or a decrease of the provisional final grade. However, if the oral verification demonstrates that the student has not achieved the minimum learning outcomes required to pass the course, the examination may be deemed unsuccessful, even if the written-exam score was 14/23 or higher.
When required by the instructors, the oral verification constitutes an integral and mandatory component of the examination. Failure to attend a required oral verification means that the examination has not been completed. The student therefore does not pass that examination attempt, and the associated written-exam result cannot be retained.
Business Game
The Business Game is a mandatory, team-based component of the course, worth up to 10 points. It normally takes place during the second part of the course and is organized around online recorded lectures, in which students learn the competitive scenario and the rules for managing their firm, and tutoring sessions, in which instructors support students in their decision-making. These sessions may be held online or on-site and will be announced with advance notice. These activities are also designed to accommodate working students or those unable to attend lectures in person, which is why they constitute a mandatory requirement for passing the course. Therefore, within their teams, students must be willing to accommodate teammates who work remotely, operating as a virtual team. Team formation is left to the students themselves and must follow the rule of including at least two different nationalities.
Team Structure for the Business Game
Students participating in the Business Game work in teams, normally composed of approximately six students.
The procedure for team formation will be communicated by the instructors within the first two weeks of the semester.
Each team designates a team leader who acts as the primary point of contact with the instructors for organizational matters.
Purpose
The Business Game is an online simulation based on a realistic competitive environment.
It allows students to apply concepts developed during the course while experiencing the consequences of strategic decisions over time.
The simulation complements the written examination by assessing capabilities that cannot be adequately evaluated through a static individual case.
Applied analytical and strategic capabilities
Students must interpret information and make decisions in an evolving environment rather than analyze a completed case retrospectively.
Decision-making under information overload and ambiguity
Whereas a written case provides a finite and intentionally selected body of evidence, the Business Game exposes students to a larger and more dynamic information environment. Students must determine which information is strategically relevant, distinguish signal from noise, prioritize competing issues, and make decisions under time constraints.
Team-based decision-making
Strategic decisions in organizations are rarely made individually. The simulation therefore requires students to formulate, discuss, challenge, and integrate alternative interpretations and recommendations within a team. It assesses not only the quality of the final strategic choices but also the team's ability to develop a coherent decision-making process.
Evaluation
The Business Game is evaluated primarily at the team level. The team score is normally assigned to each individual member of the team. This principle is based on the assumption that team members contribute appropriately to the collective work and decision-making process.
Cases of free-riding or materially insufficient contribution must be appropriately and promptly reported to the instructors. Where such behavior is substantiated, the instructors reserve the right to differentiate the individual student's evaluation from the score obtained by the team.
Detailed operational rules, deliverables, deadlines, objectives, and evaluation criteria will be communicated before the Business Game begins.
Validity of the Business Game Score
Once obtained, the Business Game score does not expire.
It may be carried forward indefinitely to subsequent examination sessions and academic years.
Students who have already obtained a valid Business Game score do not need to repeat the activity when taking the written examination at a later date.
In addition to the message sent by the online system, students with disabilities or Specific Learning Disorders (SLD) are invited to directly inform the professor in charge of the course about the special arrangements for the exam that have been agreed with the Special Needs Unit. The professor has to be informed at least one week before the beginning of the examination session in order to provide students with the most suitable arrangements for each specific type of exam.